This article, the second of two papers, looks at whether the margin on additional tier 1 (AT1) notes used by South African insurers adequately compensates for that capital and for the expected losses the capital does not cover. The first article examines how a South African insurer should treat a bank AT1 note under the country’s Solvency Assessment and Management (SAM) regime. The papers are intended for actuaries and risk and investment teams that calculate and sign off on insurers' solvency capital requirement (SCR) under SAM.
AT1 notes are perpetual, with no maturity date and no holder right to repayment outside a winding-up. The issuer may redeem them at par from at least five years after issue and periodically thereafter. Coupons are typically floating rate, and a cancelled coupon is not a contractual default and is never made up. The issuers classify the notes as equity in their own accounts. With AT1 notes, for an investor looking for yield above senior bank paper the spread may be appealing. But for an insurer looking to balance return and risk, capital and liquidity, the calculus is a little more involved.
Key takeaways from the paper included the following:
- New-issue AT1 margins have more than halved since 2019, and the terms of the notes have not changed.
- Whether that margin earns a 15% return on capital depends mostly on what else is on the balance sheet. The same note adds far more capital to a credit-heavy balance sheet than to one dominated by insurance risk.
- Under our assumptions in this paper, AT1 clears the capital hurdle comfortably for credit-light and mixed balance sheets, is at break-even where credit already dominates, and falls short if the cruder issuer-rating capital route is used. First loss after capital notes are at or below break-even once credit dominates. Senior bank paper clears everywhere.
- Insurers should deduct expected credit losses before comparing the margin with the hurdle, even when they are small.
- As spreads move over time, so should the asset allocation answer. Credit risk appetite should mean taking less risk when the reward falls or the risk rises.